Monday Market Share: C-Suite Hiring

by

C-suite hiring is entering a new era. With industries like technology, healthcare, and sustainability reshaping their leadership needs, the demand for innovative and adaptive executives is higher than ever. In this month’s Monday Market Share, we sit down with Lisa Garstang, Director of Recruiting, to uncover the driving forces behind these shifts, explore the challenges companies face in finding the right leaders, and dive into the exciting future of executive hiring.

In this interview, Lisa answers some pivotal questions about the current state of hiring for executive leaders:

  • What current trends are shaping the C-Suite hiring market, and which executive roles or industries are seeing the most growth?
  • What challenges arise in C-Suite executive searches?
  • What does the future hold for C-Suite hiring?

Keep reading to explore Lisa’s expert insights or watch the full discussion in the video below!

Current Trends for C-Suite Hiring:

What current trends are shaping the C-Suite hiring market, and which executive roles or industries are seeing the most growth?

“The industries that are experiencing the most growth in C-suite hiring today are technology, healthcare, financial services and sustainability sectors. The market is increasingly valuing executives who lead diverse teams and drive strategic innovation across complex business landscapes.” — Lisa Garstang, Director of Recruiting

Lisa highlights that industries like technology, healthcare, financial services, and sustainability are driving growth in C-suite hiring. This aligns with insights from Forbes, which emphasizes the increasing demand for growth-oriented executives capable of navigating market shifts and leading diverse teams. Companies are rethinking leadership structures to prioritize adaptability and innovation, making visionary leadership a critical asset for thriving in today’s competitive landscape.

Explore Our Recruitment Services in Emerging Industries

Challenges in C-Suite Executive Search:

What are the biggest challenges companies face when searching for executive leadership?

“Companies face several significant challenges when searching for C-suite executive leadership. Those include a limited talent pool, competition, compensation expectations, and the ability to attract passive candidates. To overcome these challenges, companies can partner with executive search firms like Blue Signal, who specialize in identifying and attracting qualified executives who align with the company's needs and culture.” — Lisa Garstang, Director of Recruiting

Lisa identifies limited talent pools, rising competition, and evolving compensation expectations as significant hurdles in executive hiring. The challenges Lisa describes are echoed in Harvard Business Review, which notes that aligning candidates’ values with organizational priorities is increasingly vital. Additionally, attracting passive candidates and retaining top talent remain pressing concerns as companies navigate complex hiring landscapes in a competitive U.S. market. Executive search firms play a vital role in overcoming these obstacles, offering tailored strategies to align leadership talent with company goals.

Partner with Blue Signal for C-Suite Talent Solutions

The Future of C-Suite Hiring:

What do you see as the future of C-Suite hiring in 2025 and beyond?

“The future of C-suite hiring in 2025 and beyond are characterized by several key trends and shifts in focus. Those include new C-suite level positions that are emerging to address evolving business needs. Such as a Chief Innovation Officer, Chief Artificial Intelligence Officer, Chief Digital Ethics Officer, Chief Sustainability Officer, and Chief Remote Work Officer.

Leaders in 2025 will need to possess hybrid leadership skills, the ability to manage both in person and remote teams effectively, digital and technology expertise, those that have strong understanding of emerging technologies and their business applications, AI powered decision making capabilities, leveraging AI for strategic insights and operational efficiency, and diversity and inclusion focused, championing an exclusive practice in building diverse teams.

Hiring practices for C-suite positions will evolve, including an emphasis on skill-based hiring, predictive analytics, and enhanced candidate experience, along with recruitment marketing. As organizations navigate the complexities of the AI driven economy, they will seek transformative leaders who can drive innovation, manage technology change, and build resilient, high performing teams. The C-suite of 2025 and beyond will need to be agile, technology savvy, and capable of leading in an increasingly digital and disrupted work environment.” — Lisa Garstang, Director of Recruiting

Looking ahead, Lisa Garstang predicts the rise of new roles like Chief Innovation Officer, Chief Artificial Intelligence Officer, and Chief Sustainability Officer as organizations adapt to changing demands. Onrec highlights the growing focus on sustainability, digital ethics, and AI-driven leadership, reflecting businesses’ reliance on executives who can navigate complex challenges. Future leaders will need hybrid management skills to oversee remote and in-person teams effectively while leveraging AI for innovation and decision-making. Lisa emphasizes that these roles will reshape leadership strategies, requiring executives to foster resilience, inclusion, and adaptability in an increasingly digital and competitive market.

Discover The Top 5 Hiring Trends for 2025

C-suite hiring is at a turning point, with businesses seeking leaders who can tackle today’s challenges and anticipate tomorrow’s opportunities. At Blue Signal, we don’t just find executives—we partner with companies to uncover visionaries who can inspire teams, foster innovation, and build resilience in ever-changing markets. Together, we can shape the future of leadership and drive your business toward long-term success.

Partner with Lisa Garstang for Your C-Suite Hiring Needs

Lisa Garstang is a trusted expert in executive hiring with over 22 years of experience in talent acquisition. With her industry insights and a results-driven approach, she has helped countless organizations find C-suite leaders who align perfectly with their goals and culture. Supported by our team of recruiting experts at Blue Signal, she delivers tailored hiring strategies that connect businesses with transformative leaders, ensuring every placement drives meaningful impact and growth. Ready to find the executive talent you need? Reach out and let us help build your leadership team.

Lisa thumbnail
Contact Lisa

Partner with us for your next hire.

Set up a free consultation with a recruiting manager. Tell us about your hiring need.

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Blue Signal via phone, email, and conversational SMS. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for assistance. Visit Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

How to Respond to Glassdoor Reviews: A Complete Guide for Employers

by

Imagine you’ve just posted a job opening for a key position. A talented candidate finds the listing intriguing but pauses to check your Glassdoor page. What they find there could make or break their decision to apply. Your Glassdoor page is often the first impression potential candidates have of your company. Think of it as a digital reflection of your workplace culture, leadership style, and overall employee experience.

When people leave reviews, they’re not just venting or praising, they’re creating a narrative that can either help or hurt your employer brand. Responding to Glassdoor reviews is a powerful way to shape that narrative. A thoughtful, timely response shows your commitment to transparency, growth, and employee satisfaction. Whether you're addressing positive feedback or tackling criticism head-on, your approach matters. In this guide, we’ll walk through why responding matters, share examples and actionable strategies, and help you turn Glassdoor into a strategic asset for your company’s success.

Why Responding to Glassdoor Reviews Matters

Glassdoor reviews are more than feedback, they’re a key touchpoint for anyone considering working with or investing in your business. According to Glassdoor, 86% of job seekers research company reviews before deciding to apply, and over 60% say they wouldn’t apply to a company with negative reviews that remain unaddressed.

A professional woman working on a laptop, with a statistic overlay about job seekers researching company reviews on Glassdoor

For employers, this means every review—positive or negative—is an opportunity to influence how candidates perceive your company. Responding shows that you care about feedback, are invested in improvement, and value employee experiences. Companies that actively engage with reviews are more likely to attract top talent and foster loyalty among current team members.

💡For Example: Consider two competing companies. One has glowing reviews but no employer responses. The other has mixed reviews, but management has responded to every comment, outlining steps they’ve taken to address concerns. Candidates often choose the latter because active engagement signals accountability and transparency. 

Proactively managing reviews not only enhances your reputation but also helps you identify and address recurring issues within your organization.  

Learn How Brand Reputation Impacts Hiring Success

Best Practices for Responding to Glassdoor Reviews

Responding to Glassdoor reviews effectively requires a thoughtful, strategic approach that balances professionalism with empathy. Whether you're addressing glowing praise or critical feedback, these practices will help you craft responses that reflect positively on your company:

1. Respond Promptly

Timely responses signal that you value feedback and take employee concerns seriously. Aim to reply within one week of a review being posted to demonstrate attentiveness. According to PR Daily, quick engagement can also de-escalate negative reviews and improve your employer brand.

2. Show Gratitude

Start every response by thanking the reviewer for their feedback. Thanking reviewers for their feedback—whether positive or critical—sets the right tone. Expressing appreciation demonstrates humility and establishes a constructive foundation for your response.

💡 Example: “Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts. We appreciate all feedback and see it as an opportunity to grow.”

3. Acknowledge Concerns Thoughtfully

For negative or constructive feedback, recognize the reviewer’s perspective, even if you don’t fully agree. Empathy helps diffuse tension and demonstrates your willingness to listen.

💡 Example: “We’re sorry to hear about your experience and appreciate you bringing this to our attention.”

4. Personalize Your Responses

Avoid generic replies. Reference specific points raised in the review to show genuine engagement. Tailored responses demonstrate that you’ve read the review thoroughly and are responding with intention, which can make your company appear more approachable and thoughtful.

💡 Example: “We’re so glad to hear you enjoyed the professional development opportunities here. It’s something we strive to prioritize for all employees.”

5. Stay Honest and Transparent

If a review highlights a legitimate concern, address it directly. Be transparent about the steps your company is taking to improve, but avoid overpromising or dismissing criticism.

💡 Example: “We understand your concerns about communication and are implementing team-wide updates to improve transparency.”

6. Invite Further Dialogue (When Appropriate)

For sensitive or complex issues, suggest continuing the conversation offline. This demonstrates a commitment to resolution without escalating the situation publicly.

💡 Example: “We’d love to hear more about your experience. Please reach out to us at [email address] so we can better understand your concerns.”

7. Highlight Positive Actions

Use reviews as a chance to showcase improvements or initiatives. This not only addresses the reviewer’s concerns but also shows prospective employees that your company takes action based on feedback.

💡 Example: “We’ve recently introduced new leadership training programs to address concerns like those mentioned in your review.”

8. Maintain Professionalism and Composure

Resist the urge to get defensive, even when a review feels unfair. Focus on addressing concerns calmly and offering solutions. Remember, readers often judge your response more than the review itself. A professional tone reflects strong leadership and leaves a positive impression.

💡 Example: “We’re sorry to hear about your concerns. We’re committed to addressing these issues and welcome further dialogue to ensure we improve moving forward.”

Responding to Glassdoor Reviews by Type of Feedback

Every Glassdoor review is unique, and there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to crafting responses. However, there are common themes and scenarios employers often encounter. Below, we’ve outlined examples of how to handle different types of feedback—from glowing praise to critical comments. While these are just examples, we hope they serve as a starting point to help you navigate even the most challenging reviews with confidence and professionalism. 

Type of Review Scenario Example Response
Positive Feedback “The company culture is amazing!” “Thank you! We’re thrilled to hear our culture made a positive impact. We’re proud of creating an environment that values employees.”
“I’ve been promoted twice!” “Congratulations on your growth! Supporting development is a key priority for us. We’re excited to see your success!”
Constructive Feedback “Communication could be better.” “Thank you for your input! We’re working on improving communication with regular updates and manager check-ins.”
“The workload can be overwhelming.” “We’re glad you find the work rewarding. We’re exploring ways to better balance workloads and appreciate your feedback.”
Negative Feedback “No work-life balance.” “We hear your concerns. Work-life balance is a priority, and we’ve introduced flexible scheduling to better support our team.”
“Management doesn’t listen.” “We’re sorry to hear this was your experience. We’ve implemented leadership workshops to improve engagement.”

Legal and Ethical Considerations

Professionalism and ethics should guide every response. Glassdoor reviews are permanent and highly visible, meaning your replies should not only address the review itself but also reflect the integrity of your company. While addressing reviews, always prioritize:

  • Privacy: Never disclose sensitive or personal details about employees or incidents.
  • Transparency: Be honest and realistic in your responses. Avoid overpromising or deflecting blame.
  • Professionalism: Even when faced with harsh criticism, stay calm and constructive.

These principles not only ensure your responses remain respectful but also help reinforce a positive employer brand. By handling reviews with care and accountability, you demonstrate to current and future employees that your organization values fairness and growth.

Discover How a Bad Hire Affects Your Company

Beyond Responding to Glassdoor Reviews: Employer Branding and Retention

Responding to Glassdoor reviews is just one part of a larger strategy—building a strong employer brand that attracts top talent and retains your best employees. A company’s employer brand is shaped by the voices of its employees and candidates, not just corporate messaging. According to Glassdoor, employee voice is three times more credible than the CEO's when discussing working conditions, highlighting the importance of transparency and authenticity. Companies that actively invest in their employer brand can reduce turnover by as much as 28%, saving costs and fostering a stronger workforce. Employer branding goes beyond reputation, it creates a workplace culture where employees feel valued and motivated to stay. When employees see their feedback acknowledged and acted upon, they become advocates, further strengthening your brand. By committing to these efforts, you not only respond to Glassdoor reviews effectively but also set the foundation for long-term success in the competitive talent market.

The Importance of the Candidate Experience

How We Can Help...

Managing Glassdoor reviews, crafting compelling job postings, and standing out in today’s competitive talent market can feel overwhelming. At Blue Signal Search, we simplify the process with custom search strategies that attract top-tier talent while saving you time and resources. We analyze your current job postings, employer branding, and retention strategies to identify what’s working and where improvements can enhance your hiring success. While we can’t change your company culture (that’s on you!), we can ensure it’s presented in a way that resonates with the right candidates. Ready to build your dream team? Contact us today to learn how we can help.

Partner with us for your next hire.

Set up a free consultation with a recruiting manager. Tell us about your hiring need.

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Blue Signal via phone, email, and conversational SMS. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for assistance. Visit Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.